
Theme: Songs from the Lennon-McCartney Songbook
It's make or break time as the nine remaining Idols give their most unique performances. There's no room for error. They must be in pitch, pick the right song and create a moment that will be a standout.
Aaron Kelly-his nickname is "Yoda"; sang "The Long and Winding Road" by the Beatles; Randy hated the arrangement; sleepy; boring; Kara advised Aaron to choose an uptempo song; old fashioned
Katie Stevens-she does a "Single Ladies" dance" very good; sang "Let It Be" by the Beatles; Best performance ever; hot; great vocal; made it her own; blossoming; sounded better
Andrew Garcia-has a great sense of humor; sang "Can't Buy Me Love" by the Beatles; Sounded better; Randy called it "corny"; Ellen loved it; Kara and Simon were disappointed; "wedding singer" type performance
Michael Lynche-is a loud snorer and was in a band with his family; sang "Eleanor Rigby" by the Beatles; Randy loved it; incredible; changed the arrangement; made the song relevant; Simon hated it
Crystal Bowersox-is caring and honest; sang "Come Together" by the Beatles; played the guitar; solid performance despite having a cold; won Randy over; Ellen could hear it on Crystal's album; Kara's favorite performance; contemporary; had backup with a digeridoo player
Tim Urban-always smiling; sang "All My Loving" by the Beatles; played the electric guitar; best performance in the last few weeks; perfect song choice; took a risk; listened to the judges' criticism; Simon liked it and was proud of Tim; very current
Casey James-is a playboy-chicks dig him; sang "Jealous Guy" by John Lennon-I'm very unfamiliar with that song; played the acoustic guitar; Randy was impresssed; soulful; beautiful arrangement; showed vulnerability; pushed himself; made it his own; showed emotion
Siobhan Magnus-amazingly weird; sang "Across The Universe" by the Beatles; Randy loved the oufit; showed a tender side; sleepy; didn't scream the song; restrained; Kara was confused; good performance
Lee Dewyze-worries too much; sang "Hey Jude" by the Beatles; played the guitar; bagpipe player backed him up; hot performance; smiled more; Kara's a fan; Simon blamed the performance on the bagpipe player
Results
Safe: Crystal, Katie, Siobhan, Casey, Lee, Tim Aaron, Andrew
Bottom 2: Andrew, Mike
Eliminated: "Big Mike" Lynche
Judges' Save?: Yes!!!-America got it wrong!!
Performances: Rihanna, David Archuleta, Jason Dorulio
Group Performance: Medley of Lennon-McCarthy Medley
Next week: 2 people go home and the guest mentor is Adam Lambert and the return of "Glee"